Saturday 23 May 2020

Google Chromecast vs Amazon Fire TV stick


Writing this product comparison since i hope it may help you too in finalizing on your decision, like
one of my friend who was in a dilemma, whether to upgrade to new Android Smart TV or wait for smart TV prices to fall?


My suggestion I would said, "I have an better option which goes easy on your pocket and also achieves converting your old TV into smart TV."

SOLUTION : Attach Google Chromecast or Amazon Fire TV Stick to your old TV HDMI socket.

What can you achieve by attaching any of these products to your old TV.


  1. Watch Youtube, Hotstar, Netflix videos on your TV easily, without lag.
  2. Cast your Whatsapp or any app video calls from phone to TV by inbuilt android screen casting option.
  3. Play games on TV using mobile as remote controller or Fire TV stick remote as controller.
  4. Cast your MS Powerpoint Presentation slides directly on large screen TV from mobile.
  5. Cast any video present locally in  your phone to TV using VLC media player.
  6. Display wallpapers on TV which change after specific interval, or even have photos of your family/friends using chromecast.
  7. Cast Mi Security camera video from camera to TV screen via chromecast. 
  8. Search or navigate Youtube, Hotstar, Netflix content using Amazon firestick remote & audio even when your mobile phone is not around. 
  9. In some cases despite having a smart TV you may face trouble to seamlessly stream content from your phone screen on to the TV, may be due to smart TV firmware bugs or some other unknown issues. But these products can save your time & mood.
Below is a detailed comparison between Chromecast and Fire TV Stick product i used for over a year. Go through the comparison and then decide which one of them is best suited for you:




Google Chromecast
Amazon Fire TV Stick
Watching Youtube/NetFlix/Hotstar Content:

Watching Youtube, NetFlix, Hotstar, Amazon Prime from your mobile is easy.

Only problem is you need to have your mobile phone with you.

You need to use your phone to navigate and select content before casting it on to your TV.

Watching Youtube, NetFlix, Hotstar, Amazon Prime from your mobile is easy.

Here you don't need to have mobile phone around you to view content from these sources.

The FireTVTick has memory to store these apps.

And you can use the Fire TV bluetooth Remote to navigate through the content displayed & launching it.

* Fire TV Stick is winner in this category.
Casting / Mirroring Mobile Content:
Casting any content from your mobile phone to TV via Chromecast is a breeze. Hence the name Chromecast !!

Cast - PPT Presentations, local videos present on your phone using VLC player or MX Player app. 

Slide show Photos from Google Photos.

Have changing wallpapers on TV screen even when mobile is not around. Wallpapers can have your personal photos as well.

* Chromecast is winner in this category

Phone screen mirroring is possible but you need to install separate mirroring apps for this.

Connecting Pendrive / HDD:

We cannot connect pendrive or HDD directly to Chromecast.

You need to attach it to your Phone using OTG & then use to explore and watch content. 

Using ESExplorer app you can search local files from pendrive or HDD attached to FireTVStick & launch local videos or watch photos.
Only problem is you need to purchase a separate connector with which will allow you to connect usb power supply  & also allow you to connect Pendrive or HDD at the same time.
you can also use the same connector to attach Bluetooth Keyboard or Game Controller.

* Winner Fire TV Stick
Searching  Content:
 
With Chromecast you require to open different apps on your phone, and manually look for what you want to watch.

Searching & getting good indexed content is easy here, but phone being near you is mandatory.






* Winner is a Tie

 

Fire TV Stick has a dedicated search tab, where you can type in what you’re looking for. But typing using the bluetooth remote can be difficult.

You also hold down the voice button on the bluetooth remote, and say your query.
You can only use it to search for any Prime Video title or an app name.

But Fire TV Stick Remote come handy when you don't want to use phone.

* Winner is a Tie

Apps Supported:
Chromecast enjoys a much wider apps support base, with Google claiming around 20,000 apps compatible with chromecast.

 * Winner is a Tie - quality & usefullness of apps may differ.

Amazon claims it has 3,000 apps, games, and services for the Fire TV Stick
  * Winner is a Tie - quality & usefullness of apps may differ.
Games:
Google Play Store has many free chromecast ready games, following are the ones i liked & were good: 

Alien Invaders - by Trapps City

Angry Birds Friends - by Rovio

Just Dance Now - by Ubisoft Entertainment

Cast Bowling

Tennis Clash 3D

Fire TV Stick also offers many compatible games app you can play.
You can connect any xbox or PS4 Bluetooth Game Controller & play gmes like

Asphalt
Retro games etc.



*Winner Amazon Fire TV Stick. The games in chromecast lag a bit. 
Price:
 INR 3499
(can purchase at 2499 during online discounted sales)

INR 3999
Links to Purchase:





Amazon’s Fire TV Stick gives you more of a traditional living room experience, where you can browse around different channels. While the Chromecast gives us a different approach and flexibility in terms of what you can do with it.  I hope above comparison helps you finalize whats best for you, depending on whats your requirement & what you want to achieve.

If you are considering upgrading your old TV to a smart TV i think Amazon Fire TV Stick will be the winner here which does more than just casting your phone to the TV.

1 comment: